St. Louis Construction Accident Lawyer
Cynthia Hennessey, Construction Accident Lawyer
Cynthia M. Hennessey is a registered nurse, a Missouri and Illinois workers’ compensation attorney, and a former insurance defense lawyer. She has spent 35 years representing injured workers, and the early part of her career representing the companies on the other side of them.
Construction injuries are rarely one injury. A man who falls from a roof reaches the hospital with an arm, a head and a spine to deal with at once, and the insurance company will handle each of those as though the other two were not there.
Reading the whole record as one picture, rather than three, is usually the difference between a shoulder settlement and a claim that reflects a career ending.
Why Falls Decide So Many Construction Cases
Of the 5,070 people killed at work in the United States in 2024, 1,032 were construction and extraction workers. Falls, slips and trips accounted for 370 of those deaths. Those are Bureau of Labor Statistics figures, published in February 2026, and they have barely moved in a decade.
OSHA groups the industry’s worst hazards as the Focus Four: falls, being struck by an object, being caught in or between equipment, and electrocution. What the four have in common is that none of them produces a tidy single injury. A fall from height is a shoulder and a head and a back arriving together, often with a nerve or vascular injury underneath that nobody identifies on the first day.
That matters to the claim and not only to the treatment. Missouri workers’ compensation rates disability body part by body part, and an insurer handling a multi-system injury has every incentive to deal with the obvious part, settle it, and let the rest go unrated. Whether that happens is decided in the medical record.
The Roofer Who Fell Twenty-Five Feet
He fell roughly 25 feet from a roof and landed on debris below. The injuries were catastrophic and they were not all orthopedic: a severe brachial plexus injury to the left arm, a subclavian artery injury requiring vascular repair, multiple surgeries, and a concussion with cognitive symptoms that did not resolve. He was left with 85 percent permanent disability to the left upper extremity, further disability to the body as a whole from the cervical spine and the head injury, and a psychiatric overlay from the trauma. He was not going back to roofing, and realistically not to any meaningful labor.
The case settled for $575,000, structured around the future medical care he was going to need.
Getting there meant coordinating orthopedic surgery, vascular surgery, neurology, plastic and reconstructive surgery, independent medical evaluations, psychiatric evaluation and Medicare Set-Aside planning. That is what the work in a serious construction claim actually consists of, and most of it is medical rather than legal.
A note on brachial plexus injuries, because they are widely misunderstood. The brachial plexus is the network of nerves running from the neck through the shoulder that controls movement and sensation in the arm and hand. When those nerves are stretched, torn, or pulled away from the spinal cord, the result can be loss of arm and hand function, burning neuropathic pain, muscle wasting and permanent weakness. It is an injury that looks unremarkable on an X-ray and ends a trade.
Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any other case.
What Actually Decides What a Construction Claim Is Worth
There is no table. Anyone quoting you a range for “a construction back injury” is guessing, and the guess is usually low, because it is built from the cases that settled easily. What moves the number:
- Whether there is surgery, and how much of it. A fusion is a different case from a course of injections, and a revision is different again.
- The permanent restrictions, in writing. Not how you feel on a bad day. What a physician will commit to on paper about lifting, climbing, overhead work and time on your feet.
- Your trade. A twenty pound lifting restriction is an inconvenience for an estimator and the end of the job for an ironworker. The same restriction is worth different money depending on what you did for a living.
- The wage the benefit is calculated from. Overtime, a second job, per diem, seasonal layoffs and a short work history all change the average weekly wage, and every weekly payment for the life of the claim is built on that one figure.
- Prior injuries. Construction bodies have histories. In Missouri, a pre-existing disability that combines with the new injury can open a Second Injury Fund claim, which is a source of recovery most injured workers are never told about.
- Whether anyone besides your employer is responsible. On a site with several contractors this is frequently the larger half of the recovery.
Missouri and Illinois Are Not the Same Claim
A great many of the people this firm represents live on one side of the river and work on the other. Which act applies is worth establishing early, because it shapes everything that follows.
- Who chooses the doctor. In Missouri your employer generally directs medical care and selects the treating physician. In Illinois you have considerably more freedom to choose your own, within limits. That single difference shapes the entire medical record your claim is later judged on.
- The weekly maximum. In Missouri, for injuries between 1 July 2026 and 30 June 2027, temporary total disability is capped at $1,294.71 a week, set at 105 percent of the state average weekly wage. Permanent total disability is paid at that same rate, for life.
- Illinois runs on its own schedule, with its own maximums and a cost of living mechanism Missouri does not have. Current figures are on our Illinois workers’ compensation benefit rates page.
The Arguments That Are Specific to Construction Sites
“You are a subcontractor, not an employee”
Misclassification is endemic in this trade. Being handed a 1099, being paid by the job, or being called a sub does not settle the question. Missouri and Illinois both look at the substance of the working relationship: who controlled the work, who supplied the tools and materials, who set the hours. Statutory employer rules can also reach up to the general contractor. Do not take the label on the paperwork as the answer.
“It was the other contractor’s site”
On a site with a general contractor, a framing crew, an electrical sub and a rental company, everybody points somewhere else. Your workers’ compensation claim runs against your employer regardless of that argument. Who else is responsible is a separate question, and it needs investigating while the site still exists and the equipment is still there.
“You were paid in cash”
You are entitled to workers’ compensation benefits whether or not you were on the books. An employer’s failure to report wages or to carry insurance is the employer’s problem, not yours, and Missouri provides a route for claims against an uninsured employer.
“Your status is the issue”
It is not. You are entitled to workers’ compensation benefits in Missouri and in Illinois regardless of your immigration status. This belief stops a great many injured people from calling anyone at all, and it should not.
“The doctor cleared you”
Carriers routinely send injured workers to physicians who see a great many claimants and very few patients, and who return people to full duty while the symptoms are still there. An independent evaluation, an expert opinion on what treatment is actually necessary, and where it comes to it a motion to compel care in front of an administrative law judge, are the answer to that.
When Someone Other Than Your Employer Is Responsible
Workers’ compensation is generally your only claim against your employer. It is not your only claim. Construction sites carry more potential defendants than almost any other workplace.
- An equipment manufacturer, where a machine, a lift or a safety device failed.
- The property owner or general contractor, where the hazard was theirs to control.
- Another subcontractor working the same site.
- A negligent driver, where the injury happened on the road or in a work zone.
These claims are often worth more than the compensation claim, because they pay for pain and suffering and full wage loss rather than a statutory formula. They also interact with it. The comp insurer will assert a lien against any third party recovery, and how and when that lien is negotiated changes what the family keeps. Our personal injury practice covers that side of the work. Where a site accident is fatal, see fatal work accidents and death benefits.
Talking to Cynthia
There is no charge to talk and no obligation. You will speak with Cynthia rather than an intake screener. If your claim is being handled properly and you do not need a lawyer, she will tell you that as well.
The firm represents construction workers across Missouri and Illinois, including St. Louis, St. Charles, O’Fallon, Jefferson City, Columbia, Farmington and Cape Girardeau, and across the river in Belleville, Alton, Edwardsville, Collinsville and East St. Louis.
Related reading: Missouri workers’ compensation, back injuries, shoulder injuries, brain and head injuries, spinal cord injuries and denied and disputed claims.
Questions we hear
Construction Accident Claims: Common Questions
I was given a 1099. Can I still bring a workers’ compensation claim?
Very possibly. The paperwork does not decide it. Missouri and Illinois both look at the substance of the relationship: who controlled how the work was done, who supplied the tools and materials, who set the hours, whether you worked for anyone else. Statutory employer rules can also make a general contractor responsible for an uninsured sub’s workers. It is worth having someone look at the facts rather than the label.
I was paid in cash. Does that disqualify me?
No. Your entitlement to benefits does not depend on whether your employer reported your wages properly. Where the employer carried no insurance at all, Missouri provides a separate route for pursuing the claim.
Does immigration status affect a workers’ compensation claim?
No. Injured workers are entitled to workers’ compensation benefits in Missouri and Illinois regardless of immigration status. This is the single most common reason injured construction workers do not call a lawyer, and it is not a good reason.
The company doctor says I can return to full duty but I still cannot lift. What now?
In Missouri the employer directs authorized care, but that does not make its doctor’s opinion the final word. The route is an independent medical evaluation, an expert opinion on what treatment is genuinely necessary, and where required a motion before an administrative law judge to compel it. Going back to full duty against your own body is how a recoverable injury becomes a permanent one.
I live in Missouri and was hurt on a job site in Illinois. Which state do I file in?
It depends on where you were hired, where the employer operates and where the injury happened, and in some situations you may have a choice. The choice is worth money, because the two systems differ on who picks your doctor and on how benefits are calculated. Establish this early rather than after a claim has been filed.
Can I sue the general contractor as well as claiming workers’ compensation?
Sometimes. You generally cannot sue your own employer, but a general contractor, property owner, another subcontractor or an equipment manufacturer is a different matter where their negligence caused the injury. The two claims run together, and the compensation insurer will assert a lien against anything recovered from the third party, so they are best handled as one strategy.
What does it cost to have a construction claim reviewed?
Nothing to have it looked at. Missouri workers’ compensation fees are contingent and set by statute, so you pay nothing up front and nothing unless there is a recovery.
Cynthia Hennessey
35 years of Missouri and Illinois workers’ compensation experience